Celebrating thirty-five years of levy-funded extension

// Extension

Thirty-five years ago, New Zealand’s world-first levy-funded Monitor Farm programme was launched marking a whole new era in on-farm extension.

Monitoring farm

The programme had a profound impact on the way farmers farmed thanks to one of its main objectives - to help farmers better understand their businesses and identify ways to improve productivity and profitability.

In part two of this three-part series, Beef + Lamb New Zealand looks back on the people involved in the early days of the Monitor Farm programme and the impact it had on their businesses and careers.

Farm System Scientist Tom Fraser  

Tom fraser

Farm systems scientist Tom Fraser was a familiar face at Monitor Farms throughout the country as an expert on forages and feeding. He said the programme sped up the pace of change on sheep and beef farms.

“They made people aware of what could be done. They didn’t hide problems and they didn’t gloss over them, everything came out, there was nothing hidden under a bushel, rather the focus was on what could be done to fix them.”

Fraser says the programme worked really well.

“There was a lot of independent trial work carried out on Monitor Farms through AgResearch and MAF and the research carried out on one Monitor Farm would be carried through to the subsequent Monitor Farm.

Tom says the strength of the Monitor Farm programme was its independence. Each farm was supported by a community group made up of local farmers- typically very good operators, who helped the farmer make decisions- although ultimately, it was down to the farm owner to make the final call.

This committee set the focus and the subsidiary topics around that, but monitoring, which was then a relatively novel concept, was central to everything that farm owner did.  If nothing else- the programme showed other farmers the power of monitoring and measuring to help drive farm performance.

Tom says often the early Monitor Farms were farms that were struggling, and the farmers were willing to admit that they were having problems in a particularly tough period in NZ’s farming history with the removal of subsidies followed by a crippling drought.

The Monitor Farms were usually medium-sized, family owned and operated farms of 2000-4000 stock units and were very typical of farms in their area. Monitor Farmers were required to be completely upfront with their financials- which had never been done before.

“They spilled their guts; they were hellishly brave as often they were struggling financially and productively.”

Monitor Farmers often described the experience as “farming in a fishbowl” as everything they did was on display- the successes and the failures.

“If we failed, we still carried on all the way through,” says Tom.

Meikle family- North Otago’s first Monitor Farmers

Meikles

Trevor and Gail Meikle were North Otago’s first Monitor Farmers and the programme ran on their 295ha sheep and beef property from 1991-1995.

In a summary booklet, published at the conclusion of their tenure, Trevor admitted that drought in the late 1980s had knocked both farm profitability and his confidence to try anything or make decisions.

“I was just backed into a cave and farming negatively.”

Debt servicing made up 34 percent of the couple’s Gross Farm Income, fertiliser hadn’t been applied for the previous eight years, and off-farm income was needed for survival.

Monitor Farm facilitator Richard Green and the community group helped set the Meikle’s long-term objectives and encouraged them to think positively about the future and make changes to their farming system.

This included selling their Drysdale ewes that comprised approximately 33 percent of the flock and concentrating only on running Coopworth ewes (later introducing East Friesian and Texel maternal genetics), targeting a high lambing percentage and harvesting all surplus spring feed. The introduction of dairy grazers also contributed to the improvement in profitability.

Instead of looking at the farm as one total system, the Meikles broke it down to different components – all of which had to perform in synchronicity. 

Trevor wrote that regular simple monitoring had been the key to identifying possible improvements and making effective early decisions.

Within three years, the Meikles' gross income doubled from $85,000 to $165,000 with a farm surplus of over $300/ha, up from $100/ha in 1991. And the improvements didn’t stop once the support of the MFP ended – just 10 years later in 2004, the Meikles weaned 162% from their 1760 Textra ewes and 97 percent from 961 ewe hoggets (their own Textras and also Highlanders reared on contract). 

Each Monitor Farm had a ‘what to do and how to do it” resource kit which included detailed information on Whole Farm Recording, Planning and Goals, Climate, Soil and Land, Pasture and Feed, Animal Performance, Animal Health, Financial Monitoring and Lamb Killing Sheets Analysis. 

This kit was available for all farmers, through Meat New Zealand and WoolPro, with the hope that the information gathered would be shared and compared with others.

Monitor Farm facilitator Richard    

richard green

Taking on the facilitator role for the North Otago Monitor Farm programme proved to be a seminal career move for young farm consultant Richard Green.

“It was a great way to build my expertise, skills and confidence. I could learn from wise heads, and it allowed me to meet experts and integrate into the North Otago community. For me it was a fantastic platform.”

Richard was then working for MAF Tech, which later became AgricultureNZ, and he recalls entering the industry at an incredibly tough time.

It was the days of industry restructure, 13kg lambs, the Rural Bank discounting and the Government’s $45,000 exit grants with farmers struggling to make ends meet. Drought just exacerbated the situation. 

Richard remembers land being sold for $200/su or $2000/ha and he wrote an article at the time saying that these prices were well above the land’s productive value.

“In the 90s it was all about survival, breaking even was success.”

“We had just come through the 80s and it was bloody tough, so there was lot of social therapy at the Monitor Farm field days. The farming community came together to talk about how they could farm in this new world, in the free market.”

His first Monitor Farm was Trevor and Gail Meikle, and he credits the couple for being so open to ideas- and so willing to execute them

“The Meikles were unbelievable; they were just so open and had the ability to sift ideas and find those that aligned with where they wanted to go and what they could execute.” 

Richard says the focus of the Meikles’ Monitor Farm programme was on sheep performance and optimising their lamb crop, dryland pastures (drought had ravaged their ryegrass pastures), summer forages and integrating dairy grazing into their farm system- the first on North Otago’s rolling downs to do so.

He remembers the Meikles being paid $8/head/week for dairy grazing, but it was very much trial and error as they came to grips with their management requirements, for example, how often they needed shifting and managing potential soil damage when it rained. 

“It was pioneering stuff, and we were looking at alternative income streams that would make the difference between breaking even or running at a loss.”

Similarly, ewe pregnancy scanning had just become available, and they were using scanning data to differentiate feeding between single and multiple-bearing ewes and improve lamb survival.

It was about identifying the management tools that could drive profit, and with Richard’s financial bent- everything was looked at through a financial lens.

As a young farm consultant, Richard was determined to make the changes work, and he says he put in about three times the hours he was paid for- and spent many weekends at the Meikles’ farm, keeping a close eye on how the management changes were playing out.

The programme allowed him to bring in technical experts, so scientists from AgResearch and Lincoln were in attendance at field days, along with experts in the business of farming.

“We had a system integration lens, looking at how to integrate the whole farm system together.”

Richard says the strength of the Monitor Farm programme was the community group. This group acted as a sounding board for the farmer and provided input into what the wider farming community wanted to get out of the Monitor Farm.

“It worked exceptionally well because of that community engagement. We had phenomenal numbers and I remember between 300-400 people coming to the annual field days.”

During a particularly challenging period in NZ’s farming history, the Monitor Farm programme gave sheep and beef farmers a sense of positivity.

David and Jo Grigg, Tempello, Marlborough

dick lucas

David and Jo Grigg were Monitor Farmers between 2002-2005 and believe the programme was the most instrumental change in their early farming career.  It helped fund facilitator Peter Anderson, and scientist Dick Lucas, who got alongside them on a regular basis. They were taught how to create a farm business plan which guided development and focus.

Dick Lucas identified that Tempello had the annual legume subterranean clover, that was being out-competed by grasses. A whole new management approach was taken, to enhance the legume content and match stock demand to when legume was available.

Peter Anderson helped David and Jo monitor and understand ewe feeding to get top performance.

The committee of farmers challenged the Griggs in a positive way and kept momentum with the changes on farm.

Other farmers within Marlborough learnt about legumes and adopted a legume focus.

Tempello has been visited by farmers around NZ looking at what was implemented through the Monitor Farm Programme. While the crossbreed sheep are now replaced by Halfbred Merinos, the pasture management and stock feeding regime is similar to that developed over 20 years ago during David and Jo’s time as Monitor Farmers.